Phil
Ochs's song, "I Ain't Marching Anymore", came out in 1965 in the
midst of social frustrations with the possible stale mate of the Vietnam War.
The Vietnam War started in 1955 , and the US got involved in 1964. Along with
the rise of the Hippie movement came the rise of the anti-war movement, which
is embodied in the lyrics of this song. Ochs captures a frustrated soldier's
point of view by implying that the war is pointless, especially when it comes
to sacrificing young lives. The song alludes to a myriad of previous American
battles, in order to emphasize the point that war is not answer, as the country
is repetitively involved. This song can be compared to Paul Hardcastle's
"19" (http://www.metrolyrics.com/19-lyrics-paul-hardcastle.html),
which also takes an anti-war approach in regards to soldiers' lives lost,
though written 20 years later. Hardcastle sings, "All those who remember
the war, they won't forget what they've seen. Destruction of men in their prime
whose average age was nineteen." Ochs's lyrics are very similar to
Hardcastles when he says, it's always the young to fall…tell me is it worth it
all." From "the battle of New Orleans" to a post-war reflection
on the Vietnam war, there is a repetitive theme of young soldiers dying for a
questionably good cause, regardless of the time period.
Nice points about kairos! I would like to know more about what was happening in the war or draft at the time this song was performed. I'm also interested in what other texts in other genres are making these same rhetorical moves? Maybe that could be part of your presentation?
ReplyDeleteThe timeliness of the song coming out is right in the thick of the Vietnam War and I wonder during how many different wars could this song have been played and be just as effective. The comparison between the other song also highlights how the emotions of the war still resonated decades later.
ReplyDelete