Sunday, October 2, 2016
Appeal to Logos in "I Ain't Marching Anymore"
"I Ain't Marching Anymore" is a protest song that goes against the Vietnam war and advocates against sending solders to fight. Although the song connects with the youth on an emotional level, the song also relies on logic to persuade. The song focuses on historical facts to discourage recurrences in the future. In a convincing manner, the song lists many battles and wars that America has been involved in throughout the years. This shows how much fighting and violence makes up American's past. Also, the song expresses the negative aspects of war, such as, "yes, I even killed my brothers". By stating these consequences of war, they appeal to the logical though process that death is bad. Similarly, another lines states, "when I saw the cities burning I knew that I was learning", proving that the past soldiers are learning the uselessness of war. Lastly, the song creates a sound argument that concludes with, "I ain't marching anymore". Another song, "Fight War Not Wars" by Crass (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jce4-CXTXzA), also has a similar meaning. This song repeats the title over and over with accompanying music ensuring the meaning comes across to the audience. The idea of fighting a war and not multiple wars plays into logical thinking, because it makes sense to do something once as opposed to doing the same thing over and over. When "I ain't Marching Anymore" lists previous wars, it also shows the idea that multiple wars are ineffective.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The intertwining of ethos and logos makes this song extremely powerful. It causes listeners to realize the reality of war and how history is repeating itself. However I would think that kairos has more of a connection to the logos of the song. The facts that are happening to the audience at that moment are events they can witness in their surroundings.
ReplyDeleteI understand the logic behind the song. It supports the argument against the Vietnam War especially to end the war draft. It is a song where the truth is in the lyrics, no holding back. The severity of the song depicts the cold hard reasons of why the draft needs to end. It expresses many difficult and hard to listen scenes of war. Similarly, in this song, "Courtesy of the Red White and Blue" by Tim McGraw, McGraw performed this song after 9/11 to support America in mourning. The lyrics in this song have strong appeals to logos as he sings about scenes of serving and representing America in war.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ruNrdmjcNTc
I can definitely see the logos in the song. It shows the ugly side of the war and how it is not doing anything but causing more problems and violence. The speaker in the song does not want to support the efforts any longer
ReplyDeleteI agree that the lyrics of the song contain names of places where wars had occurred. The facts definitely build on the logos of the song, and strongly advocate antiwar.
ReplyDelete